The Seventh Commandment

The tribute, robbery and theft of authorship, have blurred boundaries in the design practice.

Erik Spiekermann Berlin
Followers:
375
Comments:
0
Votes:
4
Compartir:

We’ve had two break-ins at our office recently. Surprisingly, nothing was ever stolen. At least nothing that we could see. We have no idea whether any data was secretly lifted from the server or ideas copied from the print-outs on the walls. If it was the case, how would we measure the damage and report it to the insurance?

It can be flattering to find work that has been influenced by your own work. There is, however, a thin line in our business between copying, adapting, imitating, or just being inspired. And let’s face it: hardly any project requires invention, because most clients feel more comfortable with something tested.

Occasionally, thieves deliver themselves inadvertently. I have seen lots of portfolios, where someone claimed authorship without justification. Large projects always need more than one designer, plus a host of other trades, be they programmers, typesetters, project managers or interns. And all of these can claim a part in the project. But that doesn’t mean they alone were “the designer”.

Whenever I show a project I speak of “us”. And it makes me proud to hear people mention the work we did together. As long as they speak the truth. It should be easy: show the project, explain what your role was and give credit to the agency or studio who you worked for at the time, whether employed or as a freelancer. Don’t forget: potential clients or employers know that it is easy to copy and paste a complete portfolio.

What surprises me most is the stupidity: people show me projects that I worked on and they didn’t, or they use versions of fonts that were never publicly available. And if they don’t send their portfolios directly to me, I see it when judging competitions or visiting friends’ studios. This is a small business. And we do talk about applicants for jobs.

Claiming other people’s work is not bad style, it is theft. And being deliberately unclear about the exact authorship is not modest, but dishonest. Intellectual property is what we create. And taking that from a designer is not flattery by imitation, but a crime.

Followers:
375
Comments:
0
Votes:
4
Compartir:

0 Comments

Comment

This article was previously published in Form magazine.

This article does not express the opinion of the editors and managers of FOROALFA, who assume no responsibility for its authorship and nature. To republish, except as specifically indicated, please request permission to author. Given the gratuity of this site and the hyper textual condition of the Web, we will be grateful if you avoid reproducing this article on other websites. Published on 11/05/2013.

Erik Spiekermann

More articles by Erik Spiekermann in English

Title:

It’s Showtime

Synopsis:

Good and bad Powerpoint.

Share:
Title:

From the C-Word to the D-Word

Synopsis:

Designers must take care of the words we use to talk about our work.

Share:
Title:

Logos to Go

Synopsis:

Corporate identity design is changing. There are designers for whom quantity matters more than quality.

Share:

You may be interested

Alukandra Coronado
Idioma:
ES
Author:

Alukandra Coronado

Title:

Qué es la tampografía

Share:
Interactions:
Votes:
53
Comments:
37
Followers:
1
Alejandra Serrano
Idioma:
ES
Author:

Alejandra Serrano

Title:

Propiedad intelectual en El Salvador

Share:
Interactions:
Votes:
13
Comments:
7
Followers:
2
Manuel Guerrero
Idioma:
ES
Author:

Manuel Guerrero

Title:

La tipografía como recurso

Share:
Interactions:
Votes:
115
Comments:
104
Followers:
69
Fernando Del Vecchio
Idioma:
ES
Author:

Fernando Del Vecchio

Title:

Sobre la efectividad

Translations:
Share:
Interactions:
Votes:
52
Comments:
10
Followers:
662
Luis Ramírez
Idioma:
ES
Author:

Luis Ramírez

Title:

Con los pelos de la burra en la mano

Share:
Interactions:
Votes:
111
Comments:
69
Followers:
53
Ricardo Martins
Idioma:
ES
Author:

Ricardo Martins

Title:

La razón principal por la que los proyectos de diseño fallan

Translations:
Share:
Interactions:
Votes:
67
Comments:
24
Followers:
78
My opinion:

Login with your account to comment on this article. If you do not have it, create your free account now.

Upcoming online courses

Branding Corporativo

Branding Corporativo

Cómo planificar, construir y gestionar la marca de empresas e instituciones

4 weeks
17 Septiembre

Estrategia de Marca

Estrategia de Marca

15 claves para programar el diseño de símbolos y logotipos de alto rendimiento

4 weeks
29 Octubre

Relecturas del Diseño

Relecturas del Diseño

Una inmersión en el discurso sobre el diseño para despejar sus nociones más controvertidas: creatividad, innovación, arte, tecnología, función social...

4 weeks
28 Enero 2019

Branding: Diseñador y Cliente

Branding: Diseñador y Cliente

Tratar con el cliente, hacer presupuestos y planificar las etapas de la creación de una marca

3 weeks
22 Abril 2019

Auditoría de Marca

Auditoría de Marca

Taller de práctica profesional: análisis, diagnóstico y programa de marca sobre casos reales

6 weeks
22 Junio 2019