Less is Less, More is More

The time is coming - to retire the nearly centenary motto «less is more».

Portrait of Luciano Cassisi Luciano Cassisi Buenos Aires

Followers:
1287
Comments:
5
Votes:
10
Compartir:

Which is better: a barroque, overloaded, complex design? Or something simpler, more austere? Industrial designer and architect Ludwig Mies van der Rohe's answer was: «less is more.»1 This famous motto has managed to implant, from the very first decades of the twentieth century, the idea of simple things being better than complex ones; that ornaments are always a spare. With almost a century of time since designers —of many areas— adopted that modern motto, it is curious that we continue to reproduce it, even when our very own daily reality proves it wrong.

What is ornamented and what is complex are part of human creation, probably in the same proportion than what is austere and what is simple. Give it yourself a try. Choose any space you have nearby and make an inventory of how many things are simple and how many are complex, and then ask yourself if the latter ones would really improve if they were like the former.

«Maxims», mottos, dogmatic conceptions... At certain times, these can be useful to fight other previously installed canons. For example, in the times of van der Rohe, of the Bauhaus, the governing canon imposed the flourish. The motto «less is more» represented a crippling blow to the creators' style of that time, and managed to pull them out of their confinement. It gave place to a new aesthetic, as dogmatic as the previous one, and in total consonance with a new need for programming object obsolescence and renovation, imposed by the economical system that started to settle in the world: industrialized products consumption economy.

Although it is true that the motto «less is more» proved to be useful for many years, during this time professions devoted to design have evolved so much. Designers no longer work blindly. We have knowledge empirically proved by infinity of projects for over a century. Before starting a job, we define with the client a specific and unique program of needs for each project, that determines, among other things, when simplicity is convenient and when complexity is, free of dogmas and marketer mottos.

The time is coming to put the motto «less is more» in the shelf of memories, due to the fact that its conscientizing function is no longer necessary, in fact it's even superfluous. It's time to abandon the figurative meaning and give words their proper meaning: «less is less» and «more and more».

The issue is so simple that we all know it: when less is needed, design is made simpler, more austere; and when more is needed, design includes decorative resources. If it were necessary to count with a motto like the previous one, it could be: «less when less is convenient, more when more is convenient».

A footnote

Every time I'm about to publish an article I discuss it before with friends. In this particular case, I find of special interest to share what Norberto Chaves wrote me about the article: «the problem with "corrective dogmas" is that they soon lose their corrective nature and remain as dogmas». Also, he reminded me of a phrase by Thomas Henry Huxley that he quoted himself on his book Desafueros: «It is the customary fate of new truths to begin as heresies and to end as superstitions​».

Translated by Joel Alejandro Villarreal Bertoldi Córdoba

Followers:
1287
Comments:
5
Votes:
10
Compartir:
  1. The expression «less is more» is usually attributed to Ludwig Mies van der Rohe, the one who made it famous, but previous authorship has been assigned to German poet Christoph Martin Wieland (1733-1813). Whether he is or not the creator of the motto, there are those who consider that the meaning usually given to this phrase doesn't match with the one van der Rohe meant. In fact, his architectonic work is not simple at all. On the contrary, he introduced during his time complexities not visible at first sight, and even less a hundred years later. His «less is more» wasn't focused on a stripped aesthetic, but in optimizing material usage and facilities to obtain performance, economy and comfort benefits, among others.
QR code for access to article Less is Less, More is More

This article does not express the opinion of the editors and managers of FOROALFA, who assume no responsibility for its authorship and nature. To republish, except as specifically indicated, please request permission to author. Given the gratuity of this site and the hyper textual condition of the Web, we will be grateful if you avoid reproducing this article on other websites.

Luciano Cassisi

More articles by Luciano Cassisi

Title:
Graphic identity: its aims
Synopsis:
Not all graphic brands are used for the same purposes. Knowing in detail the functions that they must fulfill, is essential to design them well.
Share:

Debate

 logo
My opinion:

Login with your account to comment on this article. If you do not have it, create your free account now.

Portrait of Diana Rosales B
0
Diana Rosales B
6 months ago

"Menos es más".

Como diseñadora es una técnica que me gusta aplicar en la mayor parte de mis diseños, creo que es una forma de darle elegancia y simpleza, pero también concuerdo completamente con esté articulo, tal vez es tiempo de dejarlo atrás y verlo más como una cuestión de sentido común que incluso personas que no son parte del mundo del diseño como tal, lo pueden comprender y aplicar. También creo si usamos esté termino seria más para marcar la importancia de no saturar el diseño, aunque sea un diseño complejo, creo que todo tiene un límite que debes respetar para que entonces tu diseño no se empiece a ver sucio o muy saturado sin enfatizar algún elemento en especial.

"Menos cuando menos sea conveniente, y más cuando más sea conveniente".

Cada diseño es diferente, por lo cual debemos de adaptarnos al concepto con el que estamos trabajando, y si menos es más aplica, perfecto, si no, más cuando más sea conveniente sin miedo.

1
Reply
Portrait of Ana López
6
Ana López
Aug 2013

My opinion about the second topic : «less is more» I agree with your stance, and every project is different from each other, also it has a lot of different solutions, because each project needs a specific one solution of the options (that we supposed to know), it completely envelop the designer decisions, according to their own experiences, the culture and knowledge also the context and trends. We have to define it, I mean..itʼs our job!! to determine when simplicity or complexity will be convenient to communicate what we, I mean the project want to.

1
Reply
Portrait of Silvia Calderon Iturralde
1
Silvia Calderon Iturralde
Aug 2013

Well, i agree with daniel Raposo the «more with less is better» and you are trying to express that «Itʼs time to abandon the figurative meaning and give words their proper meaning: «less is less» and «more and more»» Can you imagine a chanel Logo with barroque, overloaded, complex design? we need to comunicate in design simple but with a good concept! and this does not mean that less is less!

0
Portrait of Luciano Cassisi
1287
Luciano Cassisi
Aug 2013

Iʼm just against absolute rules. Thatʼs all. Every project involves specific decisions, they should address specific problems. Simplicity is not always the appropriate solution.

0
Reply
Portrait of Daniel Raposo
4
Daniel Raposo
Aug 2013

In my opinion all depends on the purpose and the culture in which the object will be used.

But overall, «more with less» is better.

2
Reply

Might interest you

Portrait of André Ricard
Author:
André Ricard
Title:
The ornaments
Synopsis:
An incitement to reconsider the role of the ornament on design works.
Translations:
Interactions:
Votes:
3
Followers:
441
Portrait of Norberto Chaves
Author:
Norberto Chaves
Title:
Verbal/Non Verbal as an Identifying Polarity
Synopsis:
The typological role in identity reference.
Translations:
Interactions:
Votes:
2
Comments:
1
Followers:
3123
Portrait of André Ricard
Author:
André Ricard
Title:
Design and everyday's life
Synopsis:
Designers can make a real contribution to everyday's life quality projecting low-tech objects where the shape itself allows function.
Translations:
Interactions:
Votes:
1
Followers:
441
Portrait of Ana Yago
Author:
Ana Yago
Title:
Keep the User in Mind to Overcome the Crisis
Synopsis:
The user – buyer – needs new incentives to purchase a product. It is not enough for it to be functional, it needs to fulfil the values and the lifestyle of the user
Translations:
Interactions:
Votes:
2
Followers:
17